Toldot for TAA

(Delivered November 14, 2026)

It is often said that the Torah is much too violent. Our Thursday morning study group notices it time and again. Conflict arises and is dispatched with actions more harmful than the conflict itself. And sometimes the harm arises not due to conflict at all, but rather because God commands violent action.

Critiquing the violence of the Torah is often used against the Jews, in ways that veer into blood libel. It is not so unusual these days to hear people read the words of, say, a particularly gruesome passage from Deuteronomy, not only as descriptive of Jewish culture but also as prescriptive for how to interpret current events. Aha, people say, they’ve been like that from the beginning. The land grabs, the so-called ethnic cleansing, and so on.

It’s an incredibly simplistic reading, one that conveniently overlooks the general violence of the period the Torah comes from, and one that conveniently presupposes that everything in the Torah is meant as a positive example of what to do. Although the word Torah does mean instruction, any attempts to take this wildly messy document literally can only lead to profound confusion.

I’d like to suggest an alternate framework, familiar already to my Thursday Torah scholars. To me, the Torah represents an attempt on the part of an ancient people to make sense of the world around them. That world was violent, and so the Torah describes the violence.

Come to think of it, if the Torah were to be written today, would it be any less violent? A glance at the newspaper suggests not.

It’s true that the Hebrew Bible is full of violent episodes: attacks, sieges, ambushes, you name it. And yet, it is always worthwhile to ask ourselves: what is the Torah trying to teach us?

In our parsha today, there is a small episode that perhaps tells a different kind of story about conflict. The full episode of Isaac and Avimelech straddles the first shlish [triennial reading] and the second. So as a triennial congregation we don’t hear the whole thing in the same year. But if if you’ll permit me to stray a little bit, we can tease out a subtle lesson about conflict and strife, one that feels both necessary and relevant עד היום הזה—up to this very day.

When Isaac and Avimelech first meet, distrust quickly arises between them, and for good reason. Isaac and his wife Rebecca have settled in Grar, where Avimelech is King of the Philistines. Isaac notices that the local men are looking lasciviously at his beloved wife, which understandably makes him uncomfortable. So he takes a page from dear old dad and puts on another sister act. That is to say, like his father Abraham before him, Isaac passes his wife off as his sister, in order to protect himself (and possibly her).

When Avimelech discovers the truth about Isaac and Rebecca—that they are husband and wife, not brother and sister—he is angry. (Why he isn’t deeply ashamed is another question for another Dvar Torah.) In any event, Avimelech accuses Isaac of wrongdoing rather than the other way around. It’s not a great start.

Over time, Isaac becomes prosperous, and the conflict with Avimelech only increases. The Philistines grow envious of Isaac’s wealth and undermine him by filling in the wells that Abraham had dug years before.

וַיֹּאמֶר אֲבִימֶלֶךְ אֶל־יִצְחָק לֵךְ מֵעִמָּנוּ כִּי־עָצַמְתָּ מִמֶּנּוּ מְאֹד׃
And Avimelech said to Isaac: Go away from us!
You have grown too powerful for us.
(Breishit 26:16)

After they separate, though, they’re shoved back together. And this is where the Torah gives us a different model for dealing with conflict.

This time around, Isaac has had his confidence boosted by a night vision of the divine, in which God tells him not to be afraid. When God reassures Isaac that there is a future for him and for his descendants, it puts a little more spring in his steps.

Now for some folks, having the sense of God at their backs could make them overconfident to the point of being bellicose. Feeling 10 feet tall and bulletproof can lead a person to make rash decisions. Having been undermined, disparaged, and sent away, Isaac could have taken the opportunity to rub his wealth and divine backing in Avimelech’s face.

Isaac is not that kind of person. When Avimelech comes back around, Isaac remains remarkably open and vulnerable. Rather than holding a grudge, he says his piece: מַדּוּעַ בָּאתֶם אֵלָי—why are you coming at me, since you hate me and sent me away? (Breishit 26:27)

And then he allows the moment of struggle to pass. Being able to say what he’s feeling releases whatever tension had been present, so that the two of them can move forward without rancor, and without the need for any show of force. Conflict arises, they say what needs to be said, and then are free to face the next thing.

Afterward, when Avimelech proposes a peace treaty—even though he introduces it with some revisionist history about their shared past—Isaac doesn’t argue every point. He doesn’t need to. He is able to let go of earlier conflicts rather than escalating them. He and Avimelech share a meal together, and when they wake up the next morning, they exchange oaths and part in peace.

This episode teaches a powerful lesson about what becomes possible when there is space for honest conversation, and when parties to a struggle are able to loosen their grip. A rabbi friend recently shared a Zen saying with me that I cannot get out of my head: Let go or get dragged. Isaac here allows the presence of God to help him let go, to the benefit of everyone around him. When he and Avimelech say goodbye בְּשָׁלוֹם, something shifts. Isaac becomes more himself and rather than getting dragged into generational conflict, he simply turns the page.

And God seems to favor this different mode of conflict resolution; on the very same day that Avimelech sets off, Isaac’s servants locate a well of flowing water. Good luck seems to smile on Isaac, whose brave and sensitive approach to his interaction with Avimelech opens a well of kindness and possibility for all.

Breishit for TAA

(Delivered October 26, 2024)

Shabbat shalom!

When my Akiva was first born, I fell immediately and irreversibly head over heels in love. Also, I was newly a mother and it’s fair to say I struggled with every single part of that new role. He was not a big fan of sleeping at night and the sweet personality that we now know and love was… slow to develop. Meanwhile, I was exhausted, and hopped up on postpartum hormones, with the result that, as happy as I was, I could lose my temper at the drop of a hat, and I cried with alarming frequency. As a free-range adult, pre-children, I was used to being awesome, and in this new phase of my life, I felt anything but. At some point, a very wise friend said to me: The first baby is the hardest baby, the first night is the hardest night, the first month is the hardest month… and so on. New things—even new things we look forward to and embrace, even new things that make us starry-eyed with hope and optimism and soul-melting love—are hard. Newness is hard. Beginnings are hard.

And so this week, as we find ourselves back at the beginning of the Torah, with the delightfully unresolved ending still churning in our minds, we’re forced to contemplate the nature of beginnings. Our Torah opens, famously, 

בְּרֵאשִׁית בָּרָא אֱלֹהִים אֵת הַשָּׁמַיִם וְאֵת הָאָרֶץ׃

At the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth.

About which Rashi said:

 אֵין הַמִּקְרָא הַזֶּה אוֹמֵר אֶלָּא דָּרְשֵׁנִי

This verse practically screams, explore me!

I’m paraphrasing Rashi, but only slightly. This mysterious beginning to our most sacred text sets the table for the millennia of questions and answers, and more questions that opened up. 

The text continues:

וְהָאָרֶץ הָיְתָה תֹהוּ וָבֹהוּ וְחֹשֶׁךְ עַל־פְּנֵי תְהוֹם
וְרוּחַ אֱלֹהִים מְרַחֶפֶת עַל־פְּנֵי הַמָּיִם׃

And the earth was tohu vavohu—emptiness and chaos—
with darkness on the face of the deep;
and the spirit of God hovered on the face of the water.

which sparks all kinds of questions: What was this tohu vavohu really? What about the deep, and the water? What was before the beginning?

The rabbis of the midrash practically have a party with these questions. In Breishit Rabbah chapter 1 midrash 9, a non-Jewish philosopher challenges Rabban Gamliel, baiting him with the question—and again I paraphrase: Well, your God is a great artisan but the materials were already there. The second verse talks about tohu and vohu and darkness and spirit and water… What’s the big deal? Anyone can make a world with enough emptiness, darkness, enough depth and spirit. Just add water! Oh wait, that was there too. 

Rabban Gamliel goes on to prove through scripture that God created all those other things too, that God’s labor was unbounded by time because even the things that were described in pasuk 2 were created by God, as evidenced by other verses from all over the Tanach. 

Still intrigued by the mystery of the beginning, the rabbis keep exploring. In the very next midrash in Breishit Rabbah, they spin out different answers to the question, לָמָּה נִבְרָא הָעוֹלָם בְּבת—why does the world begin with bet, in other words, with the second letter of the alef bet and not the first? A beginning that starts somewhere other than the beginning is bound to draw raised eyebrows.

The rabbis begin to answer: Rabbi Yonah, in the name of Rabbi Levi, cites the shape of the bet. The way that it blocks from view anything that might have come before it and forces us to look only forward. In this way, it reminds us to perceive the works of creation and attend to the future. The world was created with sharp-edged bet, closed on all sides but one. The tangible, remember-able world is our concern, what came before is above our pay grade. We are not permitted even to peek behind the bet. Bet is the boundary, the backstop that keeps us from asking too many questions. It’s the lock on Pandora’s Box.  

Davar acher—another take. An unnamed commentator in the same midrash says the world was created with bet to show an orientation toward bracha, toward blessing. If it had been created with alef, it would instead be oriented toward arirah, toward curses.  

For the rabbis of the midrash, whose communal memory held the destruction of the first and second temples, this approach is striking. Their determination not to look behind the bet, and their dogged commitment to seeking out blessing, have much to teach us. As we find ourselves in a world with its own measure of tohu and vohu, we can look to these ancient figures who, when facing tragedy, oppression, and destabilization, found a way not only to go on, but even to innovate. When their sense of security crumbled, they picked up the pieces, preserving and transforming our tradition. Our ancestors’ resilience can inspire our own.

So we’re back at the beginning again—a new Torah cycle for a new year, and in so many ways the world we’re in echoes the watery mess, the chaos and catastrophe of the first few psukim of the first parsha. Elsewhere, the midrashic literature suggests that God has tried making worlds before and then destroyed them: scraps on the cosmic cutting-room floor. Yet, something—something!—makes God say, I’ll try again. I can do something with this. Maybe a little light will help.

And it was so.